Usable with a quick edit8 of 10 checks passed
The evidence and reasoning are correct; only small omissions like a timeline and already-taken actions would need a quick edit.
Output
Lena, we can’t yet attribute the 6% drop to the new navigation. The timing and jump in navigation-related tickets (212, up from 40) make discoverability a real concern, but teams in the two-week beta were down only 1.1%. The decline also appears on mobile (−5.2%), which didn’t change, so navigation alone is unlikely to explain it.
Two other factors may contribute: WAU fell 4% in the same week last year, around the start of the school year, and SSO was unavailable for two hours on Thursday for teams using it (about 30%).
I’d treat the navigation as a usability issue to address, not yet the proven cause of the overall decline. We’ll compare affected and unaffected cohorts, check the SSO impact, and investigate where users are getting stuck; meanwhile, we’ll prioritize fixes for the “where did X go?” feedback.
Check by check
Got wrong · 2
- Addresses the actual decisionIt commits to not attributing the drop but does not say what result would change that answer or when Lena will get it.
- Owns the problemIt recommends next steps but does not state what the team has already done about the reported problems or offer trade-offs.
Got right · 8
- Uses the supplied evidence correctlyAll named facts, figures, and quotes match the supplied context with no invented current-state information.
- Respects explicit constraintsIt is a channel reply to Lena, under 200 words, and uses the supplied material.
- Identifies material uncertaintyIt names the unknown cause, bounds navigation with beta and mobile data, and states it will compare cohorts and check SSO impact.
- Avoids unsupported claimsCausal statements are hedged as concerns or possibilities and are tied to supplied evidence.
- Produces the required deliverableThe required reply is present, complete, under 200 words, and usable as a leadership-channel update.
- Answers the question askedThe first line directly answers that the drop cannot yet be attributed to the new navigation.
- Separates effect from explanationNavigation, seasonality, and SSO are treated as possible explanations, each with supporting or contradicting evidence.
- Ready for the reader as deliveredIt is written entirely for Lena with no placeholders, unexplained terms, or invented owners or dates.
Grades and run details
Decision model 85 · LLM judge 9 of 11 checks
Decision model checks
- passUses the supplied evidence correctly75%
- partialAddresses the actual decision62%
- passRespects explicit constraints32%
- partialIdentifies material uncertainty90%
- passAvoids unsupported claims77%
- passProduces the required deliverable45%
- passAnswers the question asked87%
- passSeparates effect from explanation84%
- partialOwns the problem92%
- passReady for the reader as delivered95%
Run
- Run
- #1
- API response time
- 6 s
- Submitted
- 29 Sept 2026